A Not So Happy 2009? Yep.

I made the local paper today with an article predicting the year ahead. For perspective, I did fairly well in 2008 but, like a lot of other folks in my business down here, many of us are concerned about the prospects for the year ahead. I don't know if I agree with a 50% drop in values over the year, but I can see some significant price cuts in BOTH lease rates and square-footage selling prices.

From the Sarasota Herald Tribune:

Unhappy new year for commercial Analysts say this real estate sector faces the biggest challenges in '09

By Michael Braga

Published: Monday, December 22, 2008 at 1:00 a.m.

The commercial real estate market has suffered this year as total sales and lease rates of everything from shopping centers to car dealerships have fallen.

But if you think things were bad this year, just wait until 2009.

"The next meltdown we are going to see is in commercial," said Gordon Hester, a Siesta hard-money lender whose customers include both commercial and residential developers. "The value of commercial real estate will probably drop 50 to 60 percent."

Investors began pouring money into commercial real estate in 2006, just after the residential real estate market peaked. Like residential investors, these commercial players abandoned the notion that properties need to kick off enough revenue to cover carrying costs, Hester said.

Instead, they banked on the bet that real estate could be purchased for one price and sold for a much higher price in a relatively short period.

"Now investors are only willing to pay based in returns," Hester said. "For that to shake out, values have to drop."

Unfortunately, the end of the "appreciation model" in commercial real estate coincides with one of the worst economic downturns since the 1930s.

Unemployment is up, consumer confidence and spending is down, and owners of shopping centers, hotels and office buildings are already feeling the pinch.

"After the Christmas season, we are going to see a ton of retailers and restaurants file for bankruptcy or go out of business," said Jack McCabe, a Deerfield Beach-based real estate consultant. "Obviously this will affect shopping centers and strip centers and the office market."

Sales dropping

The deterioration of the commercial real estate sector already is showing up in declining sales.

Only 89 properties in Sarasota County changed hands in 2008 for a total of $131.3 million, a 47.5 percent drop in sales volume from the 109 properties that sold for $250.3 million in 2007.

Office buildings saw the largest drop in dollar terms, followed by hotels and shopping centers.

"The whole thing is being driven by two things: the credit situation, which is nowhere at the moment, and investor confidence," said Stan Rutstein, a commercial agent with Re/Max in Bradenton.

Rutstein pointed to the fact that Nate Benderson, Nathan Forbes and the Taubman Cos. recently announced they were postponing construction of the new University Town Center Mall.

"If developers like Benderson, Forbes and Taubman, who are national scope, are being cautious -- if they don't want to take a risk -- then smaller players are not going to take a risk, either," Rutstein said. "Two-thousand nine is going to be a very challenging year."

Rutstein said that the only way commercial properties are going to move is if sellers come down hard on price. For example, a client who was offered $1.6 million from a bank for an acre near Wal-Mart in 2006, might only get $600,000 for that same property today.

"But there aren't any takers because banks are out of the market," Rutstein said.

The same downward trend is also affecting lease rates for both office and retail space, said Anthony Migliore, a commercial agent with Coldwell Banker in Sarasota.

"Landlords and owners are getting very reasonable," Migliore said. "There was one case in which the owners of an office building in Lakewood Ranch gave one year free rent to the Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation in return for signing a long-term lease."

Of course, that is an extreme example, Migliore said. But it illustrates the kind of lengths landlords are willing to go to get space rented.

"They may not be able to sell the space, but at least they can get it leased and ride out the storm," Migliore said.

Vacancies on the rise

"If you are a shopping center owner and you evict someone this year, you're crazy," said George Huhn, a Venice-based commercial real estate agent. "Vacancies are going to go through the roof, and everyone will be competing for tenants."

A lot of landlords are opting to carry mom and pop retailers through the bad times with rent abatements, renegotiations of leases and forbearance agreements, Huhn said.

"They're just looking to keep the guy in business, because something is always better than nothing," Huhn said.

Retail sales in Sarasota County were down by nearly $70 million, or 11 percent, in September compared with the same month a year earlier, and that was before the financial crisis really took hold. So it is no wonder that retailers and landlords alike are struggling.

But as in the residential market where foreclosures have led to amazing deals for savvy investors, the collapse of the commercial real estate sector will provide ample opportunities for investors looking for deals.

"Banks already have commercial property available that they have foreclosed on," Rutstein said.

"A good amount of it is dirt that has plummeted in value."

For investors like Michael Averbuch, commercial land represents a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.

"The biggest game in town is commercial land," Averbuch said. "Banks in Southwest Florida are nothing more than walking corpses. They are sitting on land and developer loans -- most of which are in default, and lot of that land will hit the market this year.

"The stuff is so distressed, that it can't get more distressed."